- December 15, 2009 • Posted by Michael Ferrari
- Orman Urges Consumers to Embrace "Cash Only"
-
Long supported by famed financial advisor Dave Ramsey, the "Cash Only" movement recently gained another bold-named convert, Suze Orman. SmartyPig Savers, you were at the forefront of a growing celebrity trend!
On her CNBC show she encouraged viewers to join her, "Let's go back to the good old days," she said. "Let's go back to the times when you literally paid cash for everything. That's right. Cash. Stop using your credit cards altogether."
Ms. Orman was inspired to jump on the "Cash Only" bandwagon in response to predatory credit card companies, a topic we recently covered in our blog. Moving away from credit cards en masse would send a powerful message to credit card companies that have resorted to extreme tactics such as sharply raising rates and closing accounts after brief periods of inactivity, targeting even those who use credit cards responsibly by paying bills on time and not carrying balances. If credit card companies are going to treat us as if they don't value our business, maybe they don't deserve our business.
A shift to cash only requires some initial planning. SmartyPig can be a helpful tool for saving up for specific goals. General savings accounts are great, but experts say that saving is easier with defined goals because you can visualize how the money will be spent. Simply put: you focus on the prize rather than the process. And SmartyPig makes saving easy, social and rewarding: With a competitive interest rate of 2.01% APY (currently the highest no catch rate), cash boosts of up to 12%, and the option to invite friends and family to contribute to goals, you can end up with significantly more than you personally contributed.
If you are going on a cash-only diet, we recommend that you cut rather than cancel your cards. Cancelling cards can impact your credit score, cutting them up makes them just as inaccessible. Recent stats from Experian indicate that the average consumer carries 4.5 pieces of plastic — 4.5 potential paths into debt! (Not to mention that now they can lead to sudden hikes in interest, and hidden fees.) By eliminating extra cards, you limit opportunities to spend money you don't have. It goes without saying that you should aim your scissors first at the cards that have the highest rates, lowest balances or most punitive fees.
We'd love to hear your thoughts on whether or not you already have or will be moving away from credit cards, and any tips you have for SmartyPig customers who might be considering a cash-only diet.
For additional reading on this topic, check out this post on GetRichSlowly. Staff writer Adam Baker talks about how he and his wife decided to make the move away from credit, sharing the list of pros and cons that helped them ditch the plastic.
Thanks, The SmartyPig Team
@smartypig
facebook/smartypig







7 Comments
I appreciate this post! Yes, it's time to start "owning" what we own!
I hope to have my credit cards paid off in about 14-15 months. They aren't costing me much in the way of finance charges right now, but it gets tiring juggling all of the payments and trying to find the best way out of the hole. I am now using debit cards for everything except gas, which I buy with a rewards card.
I used smartypig to save the down payment for my house, which has now been purchased. My game right now is to reduce the number of accounts outstanding until only my mortgage and student loan remains.
Personally I'm going to keep using credit cards, because I'm using the credit card companies not the other way around. First off I use no annual fee, reward cards (cash back), and I NEVER carry a balance. So they pay me to use their card. Plus even though you can get your money back for stolen debit card usage and such, they have your money and you have to wait for it back. With a credit card you can contest the charges before you pay. Also I can download all the transactions everyday into Quicken, and see right away where my money is going (Quicken for the most part can be taught to automatically categorize transactions). Of course the store still pays 2-3% on every transaction so it isn't like the credit card companies are getting really screwed, but I have a feeling that the banks get kick backs for debit cards too or the banks wouldn't be pushing them so hard too.
If you think you are going to be tempted to actually carry a balance you should certain stick with cash and/or debit cards.
If you already have credit cards balances, especially ones that are going to go up because of the credit card company are trying to beat the new laws you should look into peer to peer lending to pay them off in a known period of time (3 years). I suggest Lending Club.
And of course use SmartyPig to save for what you need before you buy!
That's an interesting thought, but I still don't like to take my chances.
I do use my debit card for purchases that require plastic, but I only keep whatever amount I need for whatever object in my account at a time.
Recently, I've found it easier and easier to use my debit card and that's disappointing, but because of that I'm glad that it's a debit card and not a credit card.
I guess for me, it's an all that glitters isn't gold type deal. There's so many "special savings" I see in stores that want you to pay with a credit card. I see it constantly. And the whole, pay a little now or none at all, then pay later with your credit card isn't all it's cracked up to be. Interest gets tacked on over time and then it ends up breaking the bank anyway.
I'm perfectly comfortable just using cash. I've been doing it since high school and it's worked out pretty well.
i did cancel my AE card...the fee was horrendous...$125 a year? no thank you. so if this affected my credit score...too bad i guess.
i still have my "miles" card and i intend to use those miles for a flight this year...so i make a few purchases every few months on this card to keep it current. other than that, i use a debit card and CASH. i continue to put money into my smart piggy account since the rates are good compared to other vehicles. thanks smarty pig!
I like the convenience of a credit card because I don't like carrying cash around. That said, I do pay off my balance every month.
Wendy,
I would NEVER have a credit card that charges me any kind of fee. If that is all they will give you, then clearly they don't want your account and you should avoid them. And if none will give you a card with no fees, then you should certainly use cash/debit cards (I certainly would).
Most people don't realize that the credit card companies charge the store every time you use their card. So they make money there, they make money on interest if people carry a balance, so there is NO REASON they need to charge fees except to people that they feel are terrible risks and in that case it is better for everyone if the card doesn't get issued at all.